There is a domestic emergency, of sorts, in
California these days. Unlike the popular
television shows, however, the nanny is the
problem, not the solution. No, California's
problem is much worse than a misbehaving toddler;
it is the overzealous politician (and those nosy
neighbors who support them). Some might call these
audacious au pairs petty tyrants, but they are
tyrants nonetheless.
Having failed to resolve such serious problems
of the day as the state's structural budget
deficit, crumbling infrastructure, declining
public education, and public pension funding
crises, impetuous politicians have taken it upon
themselves to decide for us what kind of light
bulbs we should buy, what kind of food we should
eat, and even that ever-present grocery store
conundrum: paper or plastic?
Yes, today the State Legislature is rife with
so-called "nanny bills." The following
are just some examples of the nanny measures that
are currently working their way through the
legislative process in Sacramento:
- AB 722 – Would "phase out" the
sale of incandescent light bulbs in favor of more
energy-efficient fluorescent bulbs (despite the
fact that harmful levels of mercury from
fluorescent bulbs can add up in landfills,
contaminating the soil and making their way into
the food supply)
- SB 7 – Would ban smoking in a
vehicle—moving or stationary—in which
there is a minor
- AB 86/AB 90/AB 97/SB 490 – Would restrict
the use of trans fats in restaurants and school
cafeterias
- SB 120/SB 180 – Would require caloric,
trans fat, saturated fat, and sodium content
information to be printed on restaurant menus
- AB 1634 – Would require dog and cat
owners to spay or neuter their animals by four
months of age
Then there is the recently-passed San Francisco
ordinance that will require the city's larger
grocery stores to use recyclable paper bags
(costing 3 to 5 cents apiece) or biodegradable
plastic bags (4 to 10 cents apiece) instead of the
traditional plastic bags (about 1 cent
apiece). Adding insult to injury, Supervisor and
ordinance author Ross Mirkarimi said it would be
"mean-spirited" for retailers to pass on
these higher costs to consumers instead of
dutifully licking the hand that beats them and
absorbing the losses. At the state level, a new
law that takes effect July 1 will require
retailers to provide plastic bag recycling
containers, print a recycling message on bags, and
offer reusable bags for sale.
On their own, each of these bills might appear
to be merely a minor trespass on our liberty. As
such, many might not lift a finger to fight them
and instead quietly acquiesce, but that is what
makes them so dangerous. Those small
transgressions quickly add up. One day we may
realize that all those minor violations of our
liberties amounted to a large loss of freedom. By
then it will be too late. As philosopher and
economist David Hume said, "It is seldom that
liberty of any kind is lost all at once."
In short, government is turning into the
homeowners association from Hell. It is time to
ask ourselves again what the proper role of
government should be. Government, if it must exist
at all, should exist to protect the lives and
property of its citizens against those who would
violate these most basic of individual rights. It
is not to make every decision for its citizens and
dictate the course of their lives.
As Assembly Republican leader Mike Villines has
astutely argued, "Could you imagine the
Founding Fathers dealing with—I don't
know—wearing a helmet when you're in the
buggy? We all know you can't mandate behavior; it
just does not work. It creates criminals of people
for things that are not criminal
behavior."
The point is not that recycling grocery bags or
abstaining from smoking in the presence of
children or spaying/neutering your pets are bad
ideas. It is that we should not have the power to
compel everyone else to live their lives the way
we think they should. We must be free to make our
own decisions (even the bad ones), so long as we
do not infringe upon the rights of others. If we
turn over all our decision-making power to
politicians and bureaucrats, we have become
nothing more than a bunch of sheep blindly
following our shepherd master. Then again, perhaps
that is what those in power in government
ultimately want.