I've been involved in politics since the Prop 13
campaign in 1977. I've dealt with opponents of
every stripe—from honorable adversaries to
thieves, liars, incompetents, and idiots. But in
all that time I've never felt I was dealing with a
person who was truly evil—until last spring.
What was this evil? I saw four state senators, all
Democrats, passively watch a tragic collection of
distraught and sobbing police widows testifying at
their pension hearing, suffering under the
mistaken impression that the governor's proposed
pension reform measure would cause them to lose
all their benefits, leaving them destitute. These
senators knew this was not true, but stayed
silent for political gain at the expense of these
widows' emotional well-being.
Here's the story. In February I was invited by a
State Senate committee to testify as one of the
three taxpayer advocates on a panel speaking in
favor of Governor Schwarzenegger's plan for
transitioning new state workers from the
current defined-benefit plan to a
defined-contribution plan.
The purpose of the governor's proposed pension
reform measure was to end the huge taxpayer
obligation to fund bloated, guaranteed-payout
pension plans, passed retroactively without
funding. The full cost comes due years later,
usually after the politicians have left office.
Such a modest reform is a crucial first step in
bringing our runaway state pension programs under
control.
Before we taxpayer advocates had our turn to
speak, the labor unions presented dramatic
testimony against the change. The dishonesty was
stunning.
First, a union official flat out lied. He falsely
claimed that the proposed measure would
forbid the state government from providing
either a death benefit (essentially group life
insurance) or a disability benefit to
employees. No employer in America, public or
private, is forbidden from offering such benefits,
and this union hack knew it.
Then this union boss brought forward eight
carefully selected people, each of whom had a
tragic tale to tell. The three police widows were
especially moving. The other speakers were a
burned local fireman, a shot-up policeman, a
school bus driver having trouble making ends meet,
and two school teachers—one working and one
retired. Most cried, or were near tears. They
weren't acting—these people were generally
hurting, or thought they were.
Here's where the evil became apparent. Most of
these people had been prepped to believe that they
were going to lose their existing pension or
disability benefits.
Several of the witnesses pleaded with the state
senators to not take these benefits away. Police
widows wailed that they didn't know how they would
survive without the death benefit annuities that
they and their kids were receiving. Yet not one of
their legislative "allies" at this hearing
would tell them that they were
misinformed—indeed, that they had been lied to
by their labor union bosses!
I can't emphasize this point too strongly: The
measure proposed did not reduce any
benefits for the existing employees. It would
affect only those employees hired
after June 2007.
As despicable as the union's misrepresentation was
to its own members, the true evil I saw sat in the
elevated state senate seats looking down on the
presentations.
Five state senators watched these employee
presentations, four Democrats and one
Republican. The lone Republican, Tom McClintock,
tried desperately to get the committee chair,
Senator Joe Dunn, to allow the author of the bill
(Assemblyman Keith Richman) to tell these folks
that their concerns were totally unfounded.
Senator Dunn would have none of it. The cameras
were rolling, and he wanted this dramatic
testimony broadcast at any cost. Dunn knew the
premise was false, but would say nothing.
The Democratic Party sells itself as the party
that cares about people. But you'll never see four
more uncaring people than Democratic State
Senators Dunn, Nell Soto, Debra Bowen, and
Christine Kehoe. Not one of these politicians
would tell these frightened people that their
benefits were and are safe. To allow those widows
to leave the room crying—thinking that they
were at risk of losing their husbands' death
annuities—was the single most evil act I've
witnessed in all my years in politics.
I found it ironic the Senator Dunn would try to
make nervous testifiers feel comfortable by
intoning that they should feel at ease because
"this [Capitol] is your house."
Well, I left "my" house feeling unclean
and ashamed of our state politicians. I hope I
never again witness such a reprehensible act.